A new upscale pizza option has arrived in the Old Fourth Ward. Ammazza is Italian slang for expressing astonishment or admiration, and they offer a selection of Neopolitan-style pizzas in a hip Edgewood Ave space.
Upon entering, you only see a bar/counter. Choose among a small antipasto menu, 13 different pizzas (including 2 fried options), and an an impressive beer and wine menu. A kids menu even includes something called a glitter pizza, which is exactly what it sounds like - a pizza topped with edible glitter. No kiddos with us that night, so I didn't get to sample, but the little girl in me loves the sound of it.
When you come in, you'll certainly notice the ginormous tap set up at the bar. It serves not only beer, but also wine. There was a huge selection of interesting smaller label beers, but I opted for a glass of red wine on tap that they recommended. I like the idea of wine on tap, but one word of warning. The wine comes out quite cold. Because food service was quick, the wine was still very cold when the food arrived, even after time spent cupping the glass with my hands to warm it up. That said, once the wine did warm up I really enjoyed the counter staff's recommendation (which I promptly forgot the name of!)
Once you've ordered, head around the corner to find a huge airy dining room with booths and long wooden tables. Ammazza's owners ripped out offices that had concealed the high ceilings and beams of this old brick building. The exposed structure gives the space a cool industrial feel, but the warm woods and exposed brick keep things cozy. The central long tables are on wheels, and rumor has it that late at night they might roll the tables out of the way for more of a party atmosphere.
We started with a Pomodoro Caprese. We were somewhat worried about post-summer tomatoes, but were sold on house-made mozzarella. It was a simple preparation, akin to what we make at home all summer, but the tomatoes were surprisingly flavorful and the mozzarella was gooey and salty, just like I like it.
Owners and founders, Jason and Hugh Connerty know the restaurant biz. The brothers have ties to Antico, Atlanta's most buzzed about pizza spot and Jason has worked for national chains like Carrabba's (site of my high school hostessing gig). [Jeff here: Just to be clear, Lindsey authored this post!]
Their pizza know-how was on display with the Bolognese pizza we ordered, which came topped with homemade meatballs and Italian sausage, house mozzarella, ricotta and fresh basil. Pizzas only come in one size, and it was big enough for the Mr. and me to each have 2 pieces and have enough leftovers for lunch for two the following day. The pizza had a nice char and a pleasantly chewy crust. I thought the meatballs in particular were quite delicious. This is a pizza I'd definitely order again.
We finished things off with a Torta Caprese, a flourless chocolate almond cake topped with chocolate ganache. It was lighter than most flourless chocolate cakes; and like the caprese we started with, it was both simple and delicious.
Atlanta's pizza wars have been going on for several years now, with restaurants like Antico, Double Zero and Varasano's duking it out for best pie in town. It's still early days, but I think Ammazza is a worthy entrant into the fray. In addition to the food, it has a few other points in its favor. The space is cool enough for a date night while the menu is approachable enough for families with kids. Edgewood can be dodgy, but Ammazza has tons of parking in its own lot, so getting there is a cinch.
Given it's notably closer to my Va-Hi home and has way more space than Antico--making a seat easier to get-- I suspect it might move to the top of my pizza craving list!
591 Edgewood Ave
Atlanta, GA 30312
*Full disclosure: Although my meal was comped, I always endeavor to offer my unbiased opinion of the experience!